Reading some of the review out there, I almost feel like I walked into the wrong movie theater last night. Did I see the same "Black Swan" the people who nominated it for four Golden Globes did?
I've never seen Darren Aronovsky's other apparent masterpieces (Requim for a Dream, The Wrestler) but I've heard equally shining reviews. Sounds like he has found what he likes--the dark, the macabre, the ill--and is now sticking to it.
While I won't speak for his other films, I will say that "Black Swan" is severely overrated. The total lack of a plot (mise-en-abime does not mean that you replace the film's plot with the plot of Swan Lake which is already a goddamned plot of the film) was quite frustrating. All the viewer is left with to look at is Portman's nearly-emaciated body, performing remarkable pirouettes (ballet is hard guys, I took beginning at Whitman a few semesters ago and immediately felt ugly, fat, and clumsy). And at first I thought it was going to be enough. Portman gives a fantastic performance as the timid Nina, raising neither her voice nor her eyes. Despite how annoying the timidity becomes, you have to raise a glass to Portman to embodying the character so fully. But when it comes time for Portman to play the black swan, I'd have to agree with Thomas--she's rather unconvincing.
Some people argue that they had no idea where the film was going, that days later they are still struggling to understand what was real and what wasn't. Wait, really? Because to me "Black Swan" was so predictable that the only reason I stayed to watch it was because it made me so tense and nervous I had to make it to the end for relief. From the start, the "plot" was predetermined (it had to faithfully follow that of Swan Lake, after all), and the overly dramatic controlling psycho mother figure and constant background of feather fluttering and heartbeats was just infantile on the part of the director. If you fall for that, great. You make his heart sing. I don't.
high points: Mila Kunis (except for the silly black wing back tats.. really? Because we were already so confused...), Natalie Portman's performance, Natalie Portman's black swan makeup
Unless you want a night out, I'd recommend to wait until it comes out on instant Netflix. Be sure you are in a somewhat good place when you watch it. Trust me, you really don't want to go down with the swan.